PIE vs PIH: What’s the Difference and How to Treat Them?

Learn the difference between PIE (Post-Inflammatory ) and PIH (Post-Inflammatory Hyperpigmentation), including their causes, appearance, how long they last, and various treatment options. Understand how to differentiate these common skin conditions and discover effective prevention strategies.

Understanding PIE (Post-Inflammatory Erythema)

What Causes PIE?

Post-inflammatory erythema (PIE) is a type of skin discoloration characterized by redness. It develops as a result of inflammation and damage to the skin's capillaries, the tiny blood vessels that supply blood to the tissues. This inflammation can be triggered by a variety of factors, including:

• Acne: One of the most common causes of PIE, particularly inflammatory acne lesions like papules, pustules, and nodules.

• Rosacea: This chronic skin condition, rosacea, often leads to facial redness and flushing, which can contribute to PIE.

• Eczema and other forms of dermatitis: Scratching and rubbing inflamed skin can damage capillaries and cause PIE.

• Psoriasis: This autoimmune skin condition can cause red, scaly patches that can lead to PIE.

• Cosmetic procedures: Certain procedures, such as chemical peels, laser treatments, and microdermabrasion, can sometimes trigger PIE if the skin is over-treated or improperly cared for afterward.

• Injuries: Burns, cuts, scrapes, and other injuries can also cause inflammation and lead to PIE.

• Insect bites: The inflammation caused by insect bites can sometimes result in PIE.

What Does PIE Look Like?

PIE typically appears as flat or slightly raised red or pink patches or marks on the skin. It is not caused by a change in melanin but rather by dilated or damaged capillaries showing through the skin. The color can range from light pink to deep red or purplish, depending on the individual’s skin tone and the severity of the inflammation. The affected area may also feel slightly warm to the touch.

Characteristic	Description
Color	Pink, red, or purplish
Texture	Flat or slightly raised
Shape	Variable, often follows the shape of the original inflammation
Blanching	Often blanches (turns white) when pressed, indicating dilated capillaries

How Long Does PIE Last?

The duration of PIE can vary significantly depending on the individual, the cause of the inflammation, and the severity of the condition. In some cases, mild PIE may fade within a few weeks. However, more persistent cases can last for several months or even up to a year or more. Proper treatment and sun protection can help expedite the fading process.

Understanding PIH (Post-Inflammatory Hyperpigmentation)

What Causes PIH?

PIH occurs when a skin injury or inflammation triggers an overproduction of melanin, the pigment responsible for skin color. This excess melanin deposits in the skin, leading to darkened patches or spots. Common triggers for PIH include:

• Acne

• Eczema

• Psoriasis

• Insect bites

• Burns

• Friction or rubbing of the skin

• Cosmetic procedures like chemical peels or laser treatments (if performed incorrectly or with improper aftercare)

Individuals with darker skin tones may be more prone to developing PIH due to higher melanocyte activity.

What Does PIH Look Like?

PIH manifests as flat, discolored patches or spots on the skin. The color typically ranges from light brown to dark brown, gray, or even black, depending on the individual’s skin tone and the depth of pigmentation. The affected area appears darker than the surrounding skin.

How Long Does PIH Last?

The duration of PIH varies significantly depending on the individual, the cause, and the depth of the pigmentation. Epidermal PIH may resolve within varying timeframes, though duration differs among individuals. Dermal PIH may persist for varying durations, and individual outcomes differ significantly.

Types of PIH

Epidermal PIH

Epidermal PIH is characterized by an increase in melanin within the epidermis (the outermost layer of skin). It typically appears as light brown to dark brown macules (flat spots) and is generally easier to treat than dermal PIH. It often fades over time with proper sun protection and topical treatments.

Dermal PIH

Dermal PIH involves melanin deposition in the dermis (the deeper layer of skin). It can present as blue-gray, slate gray, or brown patches and is more challenging to treat. Dermal PIH is more challenging to treat and may persist longer. A doctor can recommend tailored options based on your skin condition.

Feature	Epidermal PIH	Dermal PIH
Melanin Location	Epidermis	Dermis
Appearance	Light to dark brown macules	Blue-gray, slate gray, or brown patches
Treatment Response	Generally responds well to topical treatments	More resistant to treatment, may require more aggressive approaches
Duration	Months to a year	Months to years, potentially permanent

PIE vs PIH Key Differences

Appearance

One of the most significant differences between PIE and PIH lies in their appearance. PIE presents as reddish or pinkish flat marks or patches, sometimes appearing slightly raised. This redness stems from dilated blood vessels in the skin. In contrast, PIH manifests as brown, gray, or even black macules or patches, resulting from excess melanin production. The color variation in PIH depends on skin tone and the depth of the discoloration.

Cause

PIE and PIH share a common origin: inflammation. However, their underlying mechanisms differ. PIE develops due to lingering vascular changes after inflammation subsides. The inflammation causes blood vessels to dilate and proliferate, leaving behind redness even after the initial injury or condition heals. PIH, on the other hand, arises from an overproduction of melanin triggered by inflammation. This excess melanin deposits in the skin, leading to hyperpigmentation.

Longevity

The duration of PIE and PIH can vary significantly depending on individual factors such as skin type, the severity of the initial inflammation, and treatment approach. Generally, PIE tends to resolve faster than PIH, often fading within several months to a year. PIH, especially dermal PIH, can persist for months or even years. Epidermal PIH tends to resolve more quickly than dermal PIH.

Feature	PIE	PIH
Color	Pink, red, purplish	Brown, gray, black
Texture	Flat or slightly raised	Flat
Underlying Cause	Dilated blood vessels	Excess melanin production
Typical Duration	Months to a year (generally shorter than PIH)	Months to years (generally longer than PIE)
Affected Skin Layer	Dermis	Epidermis or Dermis

Treatment Options for PIE and PIH

Treatments for PIE

Post-inflammatory erythema (PIE) treatments focus on reducing redness and inflammation. Because PIE is vascular (relating to blood vessels), treatments often target the affected blood vessels.

Vascular Lasers

Vascular lasers such as PDL and KTP may be considered as treatment options for PIE by qualified practitioners, though individual results may vary. These lasers target the red pigment (hemoglobin) in dilated blood vessels and may potentially reduce redness and flatten any slightly raised areas. Multiple sessions may be required, though treatment outcomes vary among individuals.

Topical Treatments for PIE

While lasers are among the treatment options for PIE, certain topical ingredients can also help manage the condition. These include:

• Azelaic Acid: Helps reduce inflammation and redness.

• Niacinamide: Strengthens the skin barrier and can improve redness.

• Vitamin C: A potent antioxidant that can help brighten the skin and reduce redness.

Treatments for PIH

Post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation (PIH) treatments focus on reducing excess melanin production and promoting skin cell turnover. The approach can vary depending on the type of PIH (epidermal or dermal).

Topical Treatments for PIH

Several topical treatments may be considered for PIH management. These include:

Ingredient	Mechanism of Action
Hydroquinone	Hydroquinone is regulated by HSA in Singapore. Higher concentrations are prescription-only medicines that must be prescribed and monitored by qualified medical practitioners
Kojic Acid	Inhibits tyrosinase, an enzyme involved in melanin production.
Arbutin	A natural skin brightener derived from the bearberry plant. Inhibits tyrosinase.
Vitamin C	Vitamin C is widely used in dermatology as an antioxidant. Vitamin C is used in skincare formulations, though individual responses to pigmentation concerns may vary
Retinoids (e.g., tretinoin, retinol)	Increase cell turnover, helping to exfoliate pigmented skin cells.

Chemical Peels

While some superficial chemical peels are available over the counter, stronger peels should be performed by a licensed medical professional.

Microdermabrasion

Microdermabrasion is a minimally invasive procedure that exfoliates the skin using fine crystals or a diamond-tipped wand. It can help improve skin texture and reduce the appearance of PIH.

Laser Treatments for PIH

Laser treatments such as Q-switched Nd:YAG are available in clinical settings for pigmentation-related procedures, with outcomes varying among individuals. These treatments are typically performed by qualified professionals and may require multiple sessions depending on individual response.

Preventing PIE and PIH

Protect Your Skin from the Sun

Sun exposure may potentially worsen both PIE and PIH, potentially making them darker and more persistent. Protecting your skin from the sun may help reduce the risk of these conditions developing or worsening after inflammation. Use a broad-spectrum sunscreen with an SPF of 30 or higher every day, even on cloudy days. Reapply every two hours, especially after swimming or sweating. Seek shade during peak sun hours, typically between 10 a.m. and 4 p.m. Consider wearing protective clothing, such as wide-brimmed hats and sunglasses, for added protection.

Avoid Picking or Squeezing

Picking or squeezing pimples, blemishes, or other skin irritations can increase inflammation and damage the surrounding skin. This trauma may increase the risk of developing both PIE and PIH. Resist the urge to pick or squeeze, as tempting as it may be. Instead, focus on gentle skincare practices and treatments that target the underlying cause of the inflammation.

Treat Acne and Other Inflammatory Skin Conditions Early

Addressing the root cause of inflammation is essential for preventing PIE and PIH. Conditions like acne, eczema, psoriasis, and rosacea can all lead to post-inflammatory skin changes. Consult a doctor or qualified skincare professional for appropriate treatment options. Early intervention and appropriate management of these conditions may help reduce the risk of developing PIE and PIH.

Prevention Method	PIE	PIH
Sun Protection	Reduces redness and prevents worsening	Prevents darkening and prolonging of discoloration
Avoid Picking/Squeezing	Reduces inflammation and risk of development	Reduces inflammation and risk of development
Early Treatment of Inflammatory Conditions	Minimizes inflammation, reducing the likelihood of PIE	Minimizes inflammation, reducing the likelihood of PIH

When to See a Doctor

While some cases of PIE and PIH may resolve over time, some situations warrant professional medical advice. Consulting a doctor or qualified skincare professional is recommended in the following circumstances:

Persistent or Worsening Discoloration

If your PIE or PIH doesn't show signs of improvement after several months of at-home care or if the discoloration worsens, it's crucial to seek professional guidance. A doctor can accurately diagnose the type of discoloration and recommend appropriate treatment options.

Uncertainty About the Diagnosis

Differentiating between PIE, PIH, and other skin conditions can be challenging. If you're unsure about the cause of your skin discoloration, a doctor can provide a definitive diagnosis and rule out other potential issues.

Severe or Widespread Discoloration

If the discoloration is severe, covers a large area of skin, or significantly impacts your self-esteem, a doctor can offer more intensive treatment options that may not be available over-the-counter.

Development of New Symptoms

If you experience any new symptoms alongside the discoloration, such as itching, pain, bleeding, or changes in texture, it's essential to consult a doctor to rule out any underlying medical conditions.

Concerns About Scarring

If you're worried about potential scarring or if the discoloration appears to be developing into a keloid or hypertrophic scar, a doctor can provide appropriate treatment and management strategies.

Desire for Prescription-Strength Treatments

While some over-the-counter treatments can be effective for mild cases of PIE and PIH, prescription-strength medications, such as retinoids or hydroquinone, may be necessary for more stubborn or severe discoloration. A doctor can prescribe these medications and monitor their use.

Condition	Symptoms Warranting a Doctor's Visit
PIE	Persistent redness for several months, worsening redness, widespread erythema, concerns about scarring.
PIH	Dark spots that don't fade after several months, deepening pigmentation, widespread hyperpigmentation, development of keloids or hypertrophic scars.

Summary

Understanding the differences between post-inflammatory erythema (PIE) and post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation (PIH) is essential for effective treatment. Both conditions cause skin discoloration after inflammation, but differ in appearance, causes, and treatment methods.

PIE appears as pink, red, or purple marks caused by dilated blood vessels, while PIH shows brown to dark patches due to excess melanin.

PIE can last from weeks to months, sometimes years, whereas PIH’s duration depends on pigment depth and may persist for months to years.

Treatments vary accordingly, with vascular lasers and topical agents like azelaic acid used for PIE, and creams containing hydroquinone, retinoids, chemical peels, or laser treatments for PIH.

Proper diagnosis by a doctor is important to choose the right approach. To prevent both conditions, protect your skin from the sun, avoid picking at blemishes, and promptly treat inflammatory skin issues like acne.

---

Note: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Individual treatment plans should be developed in consultation with qualified healthcare professionals. Treatment outcomes vary from person to person, and no guarantee of results is intended or implied. All professional treatments mentioned should be performed by licensed medical practitioners in Singapore, using HSA-approved products, devices, and techniques, as applicable.